Why Critical Thinking is Key for Shaping the Future
The factors that created success yesterday don’t necessarily create success today
We’ve heard it time and time again, we are dealing with unprecedented times of change. The factors that created success yesterday don’t necessarily create success today. Business as usual does not suffice. Richard Foster of Yale University says that “in the next 10years 40% of the Fortune 500 Companies will be gone”. So, the biggest risk then is not a downturn in loss of profits for the quarter, its non-existence altogether. It is no wonder then that critical thinking, that challenges the status quo, is a core skill for leaders and our future workforce.
So, what exactly is the problem? The problem is we don’t know what we don’t know! We have worldviews and mindsets that prevent us from seeing the full realm of possibilities that lie in front of us. Ash Buchanan in his article ‘the nature of mindsets’ eloquently describes the impact of mindsets in this way “mindsets act like a puppet master, pulling the strings of our future possibilities.” So in this way, it is our deeply held beliefs, attitudes and assumptions that underpin our worldview and mindset that can both create our preferred future or de-rail it. It is our worldview and mindsets that can enable us to see new opportunities where they didn’t exist.
To ensure that opportunities are not overlooked and risks are identified it is important to challenge our assumptions and beliefs, regularly. It has become even more imperative as the economic, technological, political, environmental and social landscapes, among others, around us continue to morph and change rapidly.
There are two types of assumptions, the one’s we consciously choose to make and then the unconscious one’s, the one’s hidden a bit deeper in our psyche. These are the ones we don’t know we don’t know. While both can be dangerous in an uncertain rapidly changing world it is the unchallenged assumptions, predominantly the one’s we don’t know we don’t know, that can really trip us up the most. They can be underpinned by obsolete data, outdated cultural traditions or misinformation. And, they form the foundations of our worldviews and mindsets, which in turn create the world we live in, both individually and collectively. Challenging your used future can be an important step in helping you identify the assumptions that you hold about the future. Tuomo Kuosa can help you explore different lenses through which the future gets formed in his article here.
In addition to our assumptions there are several biases that can influence what we believe and how we stay relevant in a changing world. Understanding and challenging your confirmation bias , that pull to information and ideas that confirm your existing beliefs, is a key step towards becoming more resilient and agile. For instance, with social media we are increasingly seeing people living in an echo chamber that is constantly reinforcing their prevailing attitudes and judgements. Overconfidence bias is another trap in a fast-paced world with information overload where we may be drawn to act without taking the time to stop and reflect appropriately. This can lead to decisions made without appropriate due diligence and short term gain yet longer term loss.
In 2012, CEO Michael Cameron said in The Australian “The best way to understand what is happening inside your sector is to spend some time outside of it”. While I believe this statement still rings true, I’d like to build on this further and say that one of the best ways to understand what is happening in your sector is to spend some time challenging bias and assumptions, both inside and outside of your own sector. The next step from there, is to challenge the worldviews and mindsets that underpin the systems in place. The futures tool CLA, developed by Professor Sohail Inayatullah provides a powerful framework for doing so. Once multiple stakeholder’s worldviews have been uncovered it is also then possible to explore the shift in worldviews and mindsets that need to take place to create new systems and measurements that help shape your preferred future, not yesterdays.
Here are 5 key ways you can start to implement more critical thinking in your leadership practice and organization today:
1. Question, question, question
The power of questions to disrupt the status quo can never be underestimated. Nor can the richness that comes with understanding and including multiple worldviews in your awareness. Some powerful questions that can challenge the norm, invite inclusion and a diversity of voices in the conversation are: who wins? who loses? whose voice is missing?
2. Culture eats strategy for breakfast
Don’t underestimate the power of culture in your organisation. If you are to become an agile organisation it is important to create a culture that is open to challenging the status quo and ‘the way things are done around here’. There are no stupid ideas.
3. Become a learning organisation
Inertia is death. The leader and organisation that survives today and into the future is the leader and organisation that is open to being challenged and being the lifelong learner.
4. The power of humility and openness
Staying humble and open are vital traits as we move into uncertain and complex times. Staying open is about being willing to be vulnerable and not know, it is in the space of not knowing that something new and novel can emerge. As Albert Einstein said, “We can’t solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them”.
5. The path of reflection
Take the time to stop and reflect. Although very counter intuitive in today’s fast paced world, taking the time to reflect and learn are critical steps towards labelling and identifying assumptions and biases that prevent us from shaping our preferred future.